Spicy Yogurt Marinated Turkey

Name: SPICY YOGURT MARINATED TURKEY
Prep time: 1 h 20 min
Cook time: 3 h
Total time: 4 h 20 min
Yield: 8
Cuisine: Turkish-Inspired
Ingredients: 12-14 pound fresh young turkey; Kosher salt; Fresh ground black pepper; 3 tablespoons Aleppo Pepper (or substitute 4 teaspoons crushed red pepper plus 4 teaspoons sweet paprika); 2 cups full fat plain yogurt, preferably with pectin. I suggest Stonyfield Farm Smooth & Creamy; 3 tablespoons tomato paste; 2 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil; 1 tablespoon plus 1 teaspoon kosher salt; 2 unpeeled lemons, sliced into thin rounds; 12-14 garlic cloves, flattened and peeled (see info on how to flatten and peel garlic); 1/2 cup unsalted butter (1 stick), melted; 3-6 cups turkey broth or low-salt chicken broth

November 14, 2014 Updated April 26, 2022 by Lisa Goldfinger 23 Comments This post may contain affiliate links

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

Spicy Yogurt Marinated Turkey - with yogurt's natural tenderizing powers, this bird comes out tasty, tender and juicy with a flavorful, spiced-up gravy.

If I tell you how many turkeys I've roasted in the past 2 weeks - promise not to laugh? I think I'll wait 'til the end to tell you - better if you hear the whole story first. But I will tell you that the result of my two-week turkey preoccupation resulted in this tasty, tender, spicy yogurt marinated turkey. It's a Turkish-inspired recipe with bright and zesty flavors of yogurt, lemon, garlic and Aleppo pepper.

Roasting a turkey is challenging! How do you cook a giant bird for hours without drying it out and making it tough? Every Thanksgiving there's a buzz about some new innovative approach. I've tried so many techniques over the years: brining; spatchcocking; disassembling: basting with butter over a cloth-draped bird; smoking; high-heat for a shorter time; low heat for a longer time....

I've enjoyed many of these turkeys over the years - but not enough to stop me from searching.

What inspired me to start testing turkey recipes a month before Thanksgiving was that OXO provided me with the ultimate turkey tools and invited me to be part of the OXO TurkeyDay Giveaway! ***NOTE: THIS GIVEAWAY HAS ENDED***

When you're cooking a turkey (or - in my case - many turkeys) it's so much easier and more fun when you have great equipment for the job!

I'm happy to tell you that you have a chance to win these same great turkey tools! You'll find the form to enter the OXO TurkeyDay Giveaway at the end of this post. Good luck! *This Giveaway has ended.

In case you're not familiar with the brand, OXO is a company that makes innovative kitchen tools and housewares. Their mission is to "make products that make a tangible improvement in peoples' daily lives." I'm a longtime fan of OXO and so happy to be partnering with them on this post and offering you a chance to win these great TurkeyDay tools!

I decided to harness the magical tenderizing powers of yogurt to roast my turkey. I've had tremendous success with yogurt-marinated chicken on the grill! I was excited to try the same approach with my turkey.

My idea was to create a thick coating of deliciously spiced yogurt to coat the bird. I had a feeling that marinating and cooking the bird in yogurt would tenderize it and keep the it moist and juicy throughout the cooking process.

Spicy yogurt marinated turkey number one was delicious! It was everything I had hoped for except it was a bit burned in spots and the yogurt sauce in the pan had separated and looked a bit curdled. (I took this photo with my iPhone because I was testing my recipe for the first time)

I did some research on cooking with yogurt. It turns out yogurt becomes unstable when heated to high temperatures - that's because of its protein content. I discovered that the higher the fat-to-protein ratio, the more stable the yogurt. So using low fat or fat free yogurt for cooking is not going to give you a creamy sauce.

One of the most interesting resources I found online was a bunch of forums - Indian cooks - discussing how to prevent yogurt-based curries from curdling. The one tip that was widely agreed upon in the forums was to whisk yogurt in one direction only, so as not to break up the protein bonds. I couldn't corroborate the scientific validity of this advice, but I figured it couldn't hurt to follow it, so I did!

I also learned that you can temper yogurt by whisking in flour or cornstarch. I tried that on one turkey. It didn't seem to make too much of a difference so I decided it would be better to keep the recipe gluten free.

I tried basting a couple of turkeys with brown butter. Brown butter has a rich nutty flavor that I've enjoyed in other Turkish recipes. It was good but in the end I felt that it overpowered the gravy - I preferred plain butter.

After defatting the pan drippings, I pureed them along with all the garlic cloves that roasted with the turkey. The result is a rich, spicy gravy.

The one issue that took me the longest to pinpoint - 4 turkeys later - was that not all whole milk yogurts are created equal. Some have a built-in stabilizer!

Turkey Number One had the best coating of the first four turkeys. I used Stonyfield Farm Smooth and Creamy yogurt for that turkey. For the other three I used Fage Total Greek yogurt. After a lot of frustration with the coatings and sauce quality of turkeys two, three and four, it finally occurred to me to compare the ingredients in the two yogurts. Stonyfield adds pectin to their thick and creamy yogurt. Fage doesn't. Pectin is a stabilizer! It keeps the yogurt together - smooth and creamy - even when cooked at a high temperature.

One last finding: Of the 6 turkeys that I roasted, four were fresh young turkeys and two were free range. The fresh young turkeys were way more tender and had a lot more meat than the free range birds.

You must be wondering what I did with all that turkey!?! I gave a lot away to friends and neighbors. I made turkey soup, turkey enchiladas, turkey paninis, ~~chicken~~ turkey salad...

If you're still planning your thanksgiving menu, check out my 16 Best Thanksgiving Recipes from Panning The Globe post. I hope you have a wonderful Thanksgiving holiday!

Here's the Spicy Yogurt Marinated Turkey Recipe. If you try this recipe, I hope you'll come back to leave a star rating and a comment. I'd love to know what you think.

SPICY YOGURT MARINATED TURKEY

★★★★★

5 from 1 reviews

Author: Lisa
Total Time: 4 hours 20 mins
Yield: 8 1x

Print Recipe

Description

Tender juicy roast turkey with spiced up gravy

Ingredients

Scale

For the Turkey

12-14 pound fresh young turkey
Kosher salt
Fresh ground black pepper
3 tablespoons Aleppo Pepper (or substitute 4 teaspoons crushed red pepper plus 4 teaspoons sweet paprika)
2 cups full fat plain yogurt, preferably with pectin. I suggest Stonyfield Farm Smooth & Creamy
3 tablespoons tomato paste
2 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil
1 tablespoon plus 1 teaspoon kosher salt
2 unpeeled lemons, sliced into thin rounds
12-14 garlic cloves, flattened and peeled (see info on ten and peel garlic" href="https://www.panningtheglobe.com/aleppo-pepper-chicken/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">how to flatten and peel garlic)
½ cup unsalted butter (1 stick), melted
3-6 cups turkey broth or low-salt chicken broth

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

Rinse and Truss the Turkey Remove the neck and giblets from the turkey and reserve for another use. Rinse and dry the turkey inside and out. Set it in on a work surface or in a large baking pan. Sprinkle the cavity with salt and pepper and put 2 lemon slices and 3 garlic cloves in the cavity. Truss the legs of the turkey by cutting off a 12-18 inch piece of twine and tying the legs together (see photo on the blog).
Make the Marinade Spoon the Aleppo pepper (or the red pepper flakes and paprika) into a large bowl. Add 2 tablespoon of warm water (3 tablespoons, if using pepper and paprika) and stir to moisten the spices. Set aside for 5 minutes. Add the yogurt, tomato paste, olive oil and salt to the bowl. Mix gently with a fork, stirring only in one direction, until the ingredients are just combined. Add the remaining lemons and garlic to the bowl, and gently stir, in the same direction.
Coat the Turkey with Marinade Preheat the oven to 450ºF. Place the oven rack in the lowest position. Make sure the trussed turkey is in your roasting pan - breast side up. Pour the yogurt marinade over the top of the turkey. Lift the bird by the neck and, using your hands, smear some marinade over the bottom of your turkey. Pat marinade over the wings and legs and any areas that are bare. Let the turkey sit with the marinade at room temperature for 30-45 minutes. (Or you can marinate the turkey for up to 24 hours in the fridge).
Roast the Turkey Before cooking, mound excess marinade onto the turkey. Remove any garlic cloves from the top of the turkey to prevent them from burning, leaving them in the pan. Gently place some lemon slices around the top - decoratively, if you like. Roast the turkey at 450ºF for 30 minutes. Remove the pan from the oven and set it on a heat-proof surface. Gently pour the melted butter over the top of the turkey. Return the turkey to the oven. Lower the heat to 350ºF and roast the turkey for 2 - 2 ½ hours longer, or until a meat thermometer inserted into the thickest part of the breast registers 161F - baste every half hour with pan juices - add a cup of stock to the pan when it looks dry - if any part of the turkey is getting too brown, press some foil over it.
Make the Gravy Transfer turkey to a platter and tent with foil while you make the gravy. Remove the roasted garlic and lemon slices from the roasting pan and set aside. Pour the liquids from pan into a gravy separator. (do not clean the roasting pan) Wait a few minutes until you see that the fat has risen to the top, then pour the liquid into a medium sized saucepan. Set the fat aside.
Set the roasting pan on the stove over two burners set to medium heat. Add a cup of stock to the pan and stir, scraping the bottom with a wooden, spoon to release all of the flavorful brown bits. Turn off the heat and pour liquid into the saucepan. Add the roasted garlic to the pan. I like to spoon in a couple of tablespoons of the fat for flavor - you can leave it out entirely for a non-fat gravy or add as much as you like for a richer gravy.
Puree the Gravy Puree the gravy with an immersion blender or in a blender or food processor. Return it to the pot (if you removed it) and thin with some broth until you get your desired consistency. Season with salt, to taste.
Slice turkey and serve it with spicy yogurt gravy.

Prep Time: 1 hour 20 mins
Cook Time: 3 hours
Category: Main Dish
Method: roast
Cuisine: Turkish-Inspired